FarrierCollins’s review published on Letterboxd:
It was funny when you remember they're trying to do accents.
Finished off the Fear Street trilogy and I can safely say this was my least favourite, especially the 1666 portion. It all felt overlong, it's very dimly lit so it was tough to decipher what was happening and I didn't buy these actors in the time period. Everything felt so artificial, which just led my mind to ramble. Like I would love to just sit in on a conversation in 1666 and compare it to this and see if it's any similar. Anyways, the 1994 portion was much better for the most part. Although quick cutting and way too many flashback shots almost made everything collapse. Now I can't completely hate on this because at least it's a win for the lesbians.